Tesla Model Y vs. Volkswagen ID.4: A Comparison

The electric vehicle (EV) market is becoming increasingly competitive. Several high-end electric crossovers are now available, although they still cost more than gas-powered cars.

The Tesla Model Y is one of the first, offering its signature Tesla Model design, a high-tech software experience, and more. However, a noteworthy contender is the Volkswagen ID.4, first introduced in 2021 but promises an excellent electric vehicle experience.

In this Tesla Model Y vs. Volkswagen ID.4 head-to-head comparison, we delve into various aspects such as design, features, interior, performance, range, and price to assess which is the winner.

Tesla Model Y vs. Volkswagen ID.4: Exterior Design

First things first, let's compare the Tesla Model Y and the Volkswagen ID.4 in terms of their design, as they both take a different approach.

The Tesla Model adopts a modern approach and showcases Tesla's signature sleek look with an aerodynamic exterior, slanted headlights at the front, and an overall minimalistic design.

However, this Tesla model bears a striking resemblance to other Tesla cars. The Tesla design has remained relatively unchanged for a while, which may make it seem slightly dated, although it still maintains a generally sleek appearance.

On the other hand, the Volkswagen ID.4 offers a more traditional SUV look with a distinctive front-end design. This conservative design approach gives the Volkswagen ID.4 a unique appearance compared to typical electric vehicle designs, making it less obvious that it's an electric vehicle just by looking at it. The car features a rounded roof and a light bar that stretches along the back of the vehicle.

That said, designs and aesthetics are subjective, and your preferences and tastes will ultimately determine which design you prefer.

Tesla Model Y vs. Volkswagen ID.4: Interior

The approach taken by the Tesla Model and Volkswagen ID.4 for the exterior extends to the interior of the cars too.

In terms of car interior, the Tesla Model has a minimalistic and modern design, while the Volkswagen ID.4 leans towards a more traditional look.

Moreover, Tesla takes a clear lead in the tech department. It has put considerable effort into ensuring a great software experience.

The Tesla Model Y features a dominant 15-inch touchscreen infotainment center in the cockpit, which is known for its crisp and responsive interface. Additionally, it offers extra features like security cameras and autonomous driving technology, albeit at an additional cost.

However, the Tesla Model lacks integration with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, although it compensates with other interior features like a 14-speaker stereo system and a panoramic glass roof. Nevertheless, integrating Apple CarPlay and Android Auto would enhance the overall experience. 

The interior of the Tesla Model is outfitted with upscale materials such as suede and matte wood. However, concerns about build quality have been raised. While the cabin feels well-constructed, some describe it as plain. Despite avoiding low-quality finishes and hard plastics, the interior of the Tesla Model doesn't keep pace with the other impressive vehicle specs.

On the other hand, the interior of the Volkswagen ID.4 can be described as classy and quiet. It is well-designed, albeit somewhat understated for some tastes.

The simplicity, however, may appeal to buyers who appreciate a timeless interior design. Users generally agree that it is well-equipped with an appropriate level of finish considering its price point.

The ID.4 features a panoramic sunroof, leatherette upholstery, and a 12-inch infotainment system with a more traditional appearance. However, some critics point out that the software lags and is slightly harder to navigate compared to the Tesla Model's system.

Finally, unlike the Tesla Model, the Volkswagen ID.4 supports both CarPlay and Android Auto.

Tesla Model Y vs. Volkswagen ID.4: Performance

Both the Tesla Model Y and the Volkswagen ID.4 are available with multiple powertrain options.

Although the Volkswagen ID.4 offers decent acceleration, it falls short compared to the impressive speed of the Tesla Model Y.

With a quick and responsive powertrain, the Tesla Model Y accelerates from zero to 60 mph in just 5 seconds. For those seeking even more acceleration, the Performance Tesla Model Y provides an even faster experience, which delivers even more power and reaches 0 to 60 mph in a mere 3.5 seconds.

The Tesla Model has a horsepower range of between 425 and 455, depending on the Tesla model you opt to buy.

In contrast, the fastest acceleration you'll find in any ID.4 model is a zero-to-60-mph time of 5.7 seconds. And although it is decent on its own, it pales in comparison to the Tesla Model Y's performance.

Even the fastest ID.4 variant, the ID.4 Pro S Plus, is slower compared to the slowest Tesla Model Y, with a time of 5.8 seconds.

The Volkswagen ID.4 has a horsepower range between 201 and 295.

Tesla Model Y vs. Volkswagen ID.4: Range

Range is one of the most crucial factors to consider while getting an electric vehicle, especially for long-distance journeys. In this regard, the Tesla Model Y, once again, outperforms the Volkswagen ID.4, offering a longer driving range.

The base Tesla Model Y with all-wheel drive can travel up to 275 miles on a single charge, which is commendable for a luxury electric SUV. Furthermore, the Tesla Model Y Long Range variant extends this range to up to 350 miles.

On the other hand, the base model of the ID.4, the ID.4 Standard, has a maximum range of 209 miles. Although opting for a larger battery in the highest-range model, the ID.4 Pro S, improves this range, it still falls short of the Tesla Model Y with a maximum of 275 miles.

For long-distance driving, the Tesla Model is clearly the better option.

Regarding charging options, the Tesla Model Y benefits from access to Tesla's extensive network of Superchargers, as well as other public charging stations, which the ID.4 currently cannot utilize.

The Tesla Model Y can charge at up to 250 kilowatts, and this single charge will get you from 10% to 80% charge in approximately 27 minutes. In comparison, the ID.4 supports charging speeds of 135 kW and achieves a 10% to 80% charge in about 33 minutes.

Tesla Model Y vs. Volkswagen ID.4: Ride & Features

It's true that the Tesla Model Y can go fast and far, but it's also worth noting that it provides a well-composed driving experience too.

Responsive steering, strong braking power, and the popular dual-motor all-wheel-drive system option instill confidence in various driving conditions. Additionally, there's no reason to doubt the Tesla Model Y's regenerative braking system, which can be adjusted to match your preferences and driving style.

The biggest weakness of the Tesla Model Y is the Volkswagen ID.4's greatest strength. It has a smooth, comfortable ride but is criticized for dull steering, significant body roll, and rear drum brakes. Nevertheless, it is composed enough for everyday drives and freeway jaunts.

Regarding warranty coverage, Tesla provides a four-year/50,000-mile limited warranty for the Tesla Model Y and an eight-year/120,000-mile warranty for the battery and drive unit.

On the other hand, Volkswagen covers the ID.4 with similar basic warranty coverage (four years/50,000 miles), but the battery warranty lasts for eight years or 100,000 miles.

In terms of comfort, passengers in the first and second rows of the Tesla Model Y enjoy a comfortable and spacious ride with more headroom and legroom than in the Volkswagen ID.4. While the Tesla Model Y's third row is snug, it allows for a seven-passenger capacity, which is not possible for the two-row ID.4.

Moreover, the Tesla Model Y comes with more standard seat features, including synthetic leather upholstery and heated front and rear seats, compared to the ID.4, which only offers heated front seats as standard and uses a combination of cloth and synthetic leather upholstery.

With regards to safety, both the Tesla Model Y and ID.4 have nearly identical safety scores: 9.9 for the Tesla Model Y and 9.8 for the Volkswagen ID.4 (U.S. News safety). This is made possible by a long list of comparable safety features and similar performance in crash testing.

Standard driver-assistance features such as forward collision warning, pedestrian and cyclist detection, forward automatic emergency braking, and adaptive cruise control are present in both vehicles. However, the Tesla Model Y adds a semi-autonomous highway driving mode, offering automated steering, acceleration, and braking.

The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) has awarded its highest Top Safety Pick+ designation to both vehicles. While the Tesla Model Y has not been crash-tested by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), the Volkswagen ID.4 received an overall safety rating of five out of five stars.

Tesla Model Y vs. Volkswagen ID.4: Price

As you have seen, the Tesla Model Y emerges as the clear winner in every category, which is naturally reflected in its higher price tag.

The base price of the Tesla Model Y is $43,990 for the standard-range model, making it quite appealing for a luxury SUV. In contrast, the base price of the Volkswagen ID.4 is significantly lower at $38,995.

However, it's important to note that the Tesla model is known for frequent price fluctuations. The price provided here is accurate at the time of writing this article

Overall winner: Tesla Model Y

Competing with the Tesla Model was always going to be tough for Volkswagen. Even if we disregard subjective aspects like design, the Tesla Model Y outperforms the Volkswagen ID.4 with its longer range and faster charging. However, it comes with a higher price tag due to these enhanced features. If you don't mind the extra cost and are deciding between these two cars, then the Tesla Model Y is the better option. But if saving money is a priority, the ID.4 still stands as a solid EV choice.